Best Practices for Interviewing Technical Candidates

November 17, 2026

| 

7 min read

Two colleagues talking across a conference table with a laptop, while a third person reviews papers in the background

Engineering leaders know the cost of a hire who interviewed well and then struggled on the job. The best technical interviews guard against that by following a plan.

Every candidate answers the same job-related questions against a scorecard set in advance, and most of the time goes to real technical problems and the candidate’s own projects.

That approach predicts job performance better than an open conversation, and it’s also the most reliable way to tell a candidate’s own thinking apart from an answer an AI tool wrote.


Why structure beats gut feel

In a 2022 review in the Journal of Applied Psychology, Paul Sackett and colleagues re-examined decades of research on hiring methods. Structured interviews came out as the strongest predictor of job performance among the methods they studied, with a mean validity of .42.

The same review found wide variation from study to study. Structured interviews work best when they’re built from the actual job and run by interviewers who know how to use them. A list of questions handed to a busy manager the morning of the interview doesn’t qualify.

We covered the building blocks, like defined competencies and consistent questions, in The biggest interviewing mistakes hiring managers make. This post focuses on what changes when the role is technical.


Bring the real work into the interview

A technical résumé lists tools and certifications. What it can’t show is how someone works through a problem they haven’t seen before, and that’s the skill you’re hiring for.

A short work sample tied to the job, like a drawing to mark up or a failure log to diagnose, gives the candidate something concrete to reason through out loud. Keep it short enough to finish during the interview, and score it against the same scorecard as the rest of the conversation.

Then ask about the candidate’s own projects. Start with something like: “Walk me through a technical decision on a recent project that you would make differently now.” Let the follow-up questions do the work. What other options did you consider? What did the testing or data show? Who disagreed with you, and how did that get resolved? What would you change next time?

Strong engineers get more specific as you dig. Weaker candidates get vaguer, or they circle back to the same polished summary.

One more point for engineering leaders: separate what a candidate must bring on day one from what your team can teach. A candidate who knows the fundamentals but hasn’t used your exact software can be a better hire than one who knows the tool and struggles with the underlying problem. Screening out the first group over a tool they could learn in a month shrinks a pool that’s already small.


Interviewing when candidates have AI

AI has changed what an interview has to test. In Gartner’s research, 39% of 3,290 candidates surveyed in late 2024 said they used AI during the application process. In a separate 2025 survey of 3,000 candidates, 6% admitted to interview fraud, either posing as someone else or having someone pose as them. Gartner predicts that by 2028, one in four candidate profiles worldwide will be fake.

Most of that AI use is ordinary. Among candidates who used AI, 54% used it to write résumé text and 50% used it for cover letters. Smaller shares used it for writing samples (36%) and for answers to assessment questions (29%). That last group matters most in technical hiring, because a take-home assessment is easy to hand to a tool.

The real risk comes when the words in the interview belong to a tool, or the person on screen isn’t who they claim to be. Four steps help with both.

Move the assessment into the interview. A work sample done live, with the candidate explaining each step, shows their reasoning in real time. A take-home test shows only the finished answer, with no way to know who or what produced it.

Let follow-up questions do the checking. An AI tool can produce a confident first answer to almost any technical question. It struggles with the personal specifics follow-ups demand, like the reason the first fix failed or the colleague who pushed back. Answers that stay polished and general no matter how far you dig deserve a closer look. Pay attention to timing, too. A long, unusual pause between your question and the candidate’s answer can mean a tool is generating the response.

Set expectations up front. Tell candidates how your company defines acceptable AI use. Gartner recommends this as a first step, along with being open about your fraud detection efforts.

Verify identity before the final round. Gartner also recommends building checks such as identity verification and background screening into the hiring process itself, so interviewers aren’t the only line of defense. For critical roles, consider an in-person final interview. In Gartner’s research, 62% of candidates said they’re more likely to apply when an employer requires in-person interviews, so this step doesn’t have to cost you good applicants.


Put an engineer in the room

A recruiter can assess motivation and culture fit. Judging whether a candidate’s approach to a tolerance stack-up problem is sound takes someone who has solved that kind of problem before.

Have a senior engineer or the hiring manager own the technical portion of the interview, including the work sample. Their read on the candidate’s reasoning is the most important evidence in the debrief. For running a panel well, see our guide to best practices for panel interviews.

This is central to how DISHER Talent works. DISHER is an engineering firm as well as a recruiting firm, so our recruiters work alongside DISHER engineers who help vet roles and evaluate candidates.


Keep strong candidates in the process

Strong technical candidates have options, and the interview is where they decide whether to use them on you. Gartner found that only 51% of candidates accepted a job offer in their most recent application process in 2025, down from 74% two years earlier.

Give the technical interviewer time to talk about the real work the team is doing, because engineers want to know what they’d be building. For more on the candidate side, see our post on improving candidate experience during interviews.


Frequently Asked Questions

How many interview rounds should a technical hire take?

Three rounds is usually enough for most engineering hires, based on DISHER’s experience with engineering searches. Each added round extends the timeline and can signal friction to candidates who are weighing your culture alongside the role.

How soon should we follow up after a technical interview?

Within 48 hours for qualified candidates. Strong engineers often have other offers in play, and a slow response gives a competitor time to move first.

Should candidates be allowed to use AI during a technical interview?

That’s a policy decision to make on purpose and share with candidates before the interview. Where engineers on your team already use AI tools in their daily work, a blanket ban may not match the job. Whatever you decide, apply it consistently. The live portion of the interview should still show the candidate’s own reasoning.

Can early interview rounds stay remote?

Yes. Remote screens work well for early rounds, especially with a live work sample on camera. Save the in-person step for the final round of critical roles, where identity verification matters most.


Build an interview process engineers respect

A better interview starts with a better plan for the role. DISHER Talent helps engineering leaders find and vet technical candidates, and we offer an Interview workshop for hiring teams through our training program.

Book a consult with a DISHER Talent specialist and let’s start with your hardest-to-fill role.

Talk to a Talent Specialist
Content Team

Written By:

DISHER Talent | Content Team